Reflections on Passover, Redemption, and the Gatekeepers in Tel Aviv

It’s one thing to watch a film like The Gatekeepers from the comfort of the diaspora. It’s another thing entirely to watch it in the heart of Israel. The people in the  film were well known and part of the public sphere. The horrific events chronicled in the pictures of bombed buses and mangled corpses happened in the streets of Tel Aviv. The images of Israeli soldiers, patrolling in the occupied territories, fighting during the First Intifada, and arresting Palestinians were familiar, too. Some of those soldiers were now sitting and watching the film.

The audience experienced the film viscerally. After each segment, the audience breathed a deep collective sigh, as if it were in pain. One viewer near me remarked that he remembered blindfolding Palestinians and binding their hands during a military operation. When Avraham Shalom, head of the Shin Bet from 1981-86,  grumbled that in war there are no morals and that if you’re concerned about morals look for them in the terrorists first, a woman behind me muttered that he sounded like an idiot. A different woman said he reminded her of the Nazis. And another said that she had waited for the film to end, not because it was bad but because it was so difficult and aching to watch. When the movie ended and the lights came on, the audience struggled to stand. The film had knocked the wind out of them.

For a Jew in Israel, the film is disturbing because it illuminates the vast apparatus of violence and oppression that I am part of. It shows the military mechanisms used to construct the reality in which I live. It describes the actions which I knew happened but did not want to know about. It points out the rifts in Israeli society that have influenced not only the public political discourse but also the language used by Jews all around the world in the way they relate to Israel.

It is frightening because it concludes with a prediction for the future – one of more death, oppression, and violence. It reminded me that at the end of the year, when I have the privilege of returning to study at college in the US, my friends from the mechina will be thrust into the vicious cycle of violence. Some of them will serve in combat units in the West Bank. Some will be in the intelligence units spoken about in the film. Some will be in the same air-force that carries out targeted assassinations. I can only understand the film from my subjective viewpoint. I can only attempt to imagine what a future like theirs might be like.

I know that what I say here is colored the temporary-ness of my presence in Israel. I’m a visitor, a cultural tourist. I have the option of tuning out, of leaving and, most of all, of taking a stance without having to deal with the consequences. I’m not going to be conscripted at the end of this year. I can unconditionally oppose the occupation and Israeli policies without worrying about what will happen when I enlist. I can’t ask my friends to refuse to enlist – not with the cost it comes with in Israeli society, not with the threat of jail time. But there are other gears and levers in the terrible machine of military occupation. There are other variables in the sinister equation that can be changed.

Complicity, culpability, and responsibility for the occupation do not end at Israel’s borders. In the diaspora, it is fashionable amongst self-described supporters of Israel to label even Jewish critics of Zionism and Israeli policy “anti-semitic” or “anti-Israel” for choosing Israel out of all the other terrible regimes in the Middle East for rebuke. And yet those self-described supporters of Israel completely fail to understand, and here I can only speak for myself, that criticism of Israel and its policies does not come from a place of hatred (or self-hatred) or naïveté. Instead, it comes from a deep concern for the Jewish people and its moral integrity. The occupation first and foremost deprives Palestinians of their most basic rights and freedoms. But it also threatens the ethical character of the Jewish people and the state of Israel. The occupation has turned Jews – and those in the diaspora are some of the greatest offenders – into a nation that exercises and justifies the military domination of another nation. It has turned Israel into a state concerned firstly with separation and violence rather than with justice and peace. It has warped the interpretation of Jewish scripture, which once brought  Jews to march alongside Martin Luther King Jr., into a basis for chauvinistic and racist demagoguery.

When an injustice is sustained for so long, it begins to poison its sustainers. American Jewish supporters of Israel have turned into apologists for discrimination, legitimizers of occupation, and supporters of endless violence. For all its talk about social justice, the American Jewish community has done more than check its liberalism at Zionism’s door. It has put Jewish scripture in the service of jingoism, militarism, and racism. And in doing so it has disgraced not just the rich modern history of Jewish participation in the struggle for human rights but also the words of the prophets and the spirit of the mitzvoth.

Part of the film shows the apprehension of the violent Jewish Underground- the group of that attempted to blow up Palestinian buses and threatened to destroy the Dome of the Rock. And as I watched the despicable members of that organization flicker across the screen I felt a pang of guilt. That they wore kippot, just like I did. That they celebrated Shabbat, just like I did. That they considered themselves part of the same Jewish people as I did. They looked like my friends and family.

As Pesach approaches I cannot help but think that  in the modern iteration of the story we have become the Egyptians, and that the protesters massing peacefully in Nabi Saleh, Sheikh Jarrah, Bil’in, Ni’lin, Hebron, Bethlehem, Ramallah, Susya, and Jerusalem are Bnei Yisrael desperately crying out for freedom. Amidst the smoke and the tear gas, they cry out “let my people go.” And we respond with rubber bullets and brutal beatings. It is as if, in a tragic reverse of fate, God has hardened our hearts towards the suffering of the people we control. To each protest we react with disdain, to each spasm of resistance we respond with contempt, and to each cry for help we reply with indifference. Just as we wish for at the end of the seder, Palestinians wish to spend next year in Jerusalem, too. To pray at their holy sites free from the gaze heavily armed soldiers. To travel without suffering abuse and humiliation at the checkpoints. To make the political decisions that affect their lives rather than have those decisions thrust upon them by an occupying force.

The Israeli scientist and philosopher Yeshayahu Leibowitz argued “Jewish uniqueness ‘is not a fact; it is an endeavor. The holiness of Israel is not a reality but a task.’ The Jewish people’s uniqueness rather consists in the demand laid on it. The people may or may not heed this demand, therefore its fate is not guaranteed.'” The Gatekeepers, loudly and clearly, announced that now, more than at anytime since the establishment of the state of Israel, the Jewish people’s fate is uncertain. We are failing in our endeavor towards holiness. We are failing to meet the demand. We are failing to fulfill the commandments that we are obligated to fulfill. We are failing to bring about redemption (גאולה). In the story of Pesach, the Jewish people are redeemed – from slavery to freedom. But that was only one kind of redemption – one stage in the redemptive process. In a world filled with injustice we must strive, again, for redemption. And the occupation is the greatest obstacle that stands in the way of the Jewish people’s modern redemptive quest.

The greatest threat to the future of Israel is not posed by Arabs or Leftists but by those who call themselves Zionists. Each day that goes by without a halt to settlement building makes the possibility of withdrawal from the West Bank less likely. And each day that the occupation continues makes it more difficult to achieve a lasting peace. What right-wing Israelis and AIPAC supporters alike fail to realize is that maintaining the status quo means surrendering forever the dream of a Jewish state. Israel must end the occupation or let Palestinians vote in general elections.

Even in a world of nuance, here there is no in-between. Maintaining the occupation means maintaining apartheid. It corrupts Judaism. It destroys the powerful emancipatory tradition of the Jewish people. We stand on the precipice of a catastrophe that will be the legacy of the religious-Zionist movement that wrongly insisted on the inherent holiness of the land. It will be the fault of an American Jewish community that sat idly by as it funded a tyrannical system of oppression and silenced any criticism from within. And it will be the second greatest tragedy in modern Jewish history.

This entry was posted in Ideology, Israel, Judaism, Religion, Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Reflections on Passover, Redemption, and the Gatekeepers in Tel Aviv

  1. To reply to your essay here, would amount to a thesis of considerable effort and detail. I am certain of one thing, which I can summarize quickly: Your assertions are as skewed as the heads of a hard drive that has been dropped onto a hard surface.

    I have spent much time inside and outside of Israel, collecting independent data, testimonies, and making friends of Egyptians, Persians (There are many who refuse to call themselves Iranians, with good cause, but that is another story for another day), Arabs, Ashkenazi and Sephardic Jews, secular Jews, cultural Jews, Zionist and anti-Zionist Jews, Armenians, Christians of every sect and denomination you can imagine, and here is the collective reality: The outspoken few DO NOT speak for the marginalized majority.

    It has been that way in America for decades before you were even born, that I experienced. Again, you sound like a parrot, I can anticipate your words before I actually read them, they are so discernibly predictable.

    As I stressed in a previous post, you lack critical thinking and analytical skills to sift out the rhetorical kitty litter from the sand. You have to look critically at who is speaking, and then ask what manner they speak, how they speak, why they speak, etc. Those outspoken as they are, have an agenda. So do those who have groomed your thinking to taint your vision from any sort of objectivity.

    If you were an airplane, your left wing would be scraping the ground, and causing effective flight or movement from taking place. That is because all the weight is on the one side, as I alluded to earlier. This radicalizes your views, and if anything, you are as much “jingoistic,” if not more than those you accuse of being so. Only your allegiance is to your ideology, not a country.

    You offer no concession, no reconciliation, no quarter, no tact or diplomacy with those who differ in their views or understanding. Instead, you impose your views with this angry voice as I see in this background image on this web page, and everyone else is forced into silence as you try to have your “15 minutes of notoriety or fame.”

    The fruit of your actions, then, has largely galvanized an opposing mindset against your provocative actions and remarks. The editorial write-ups and public reaction demonstrate this. Your blogs here may tell the tale of your self-righteous conquest to address the issues you are confronting, however, the rest of the world is largely in disagreement with your assertions.

    I suggest you go through them all, and do a “post mortem” of this whole affair, and see the bigger picture here. I also suggest that you start drafting heart-felt, earnest letters of apology to those who graciously hosted your visit to Israel, and humble yourself for abusing their gracious and generous gift, that many believe you blatantly abused.

    Finally, I suggest you cease and desist with your moralistic platitudes that you dispense with dizzying frequency, along with the predictable rhetoric you were dispensing as well. As Proverbs states, A wise man who heeds correction will love you, but a fool will despise you.”

    What spirit are you of, Josh? Now the line is drawn in the sand, either you will take one road or the other. The Solomon’s wisdom stands in waiting to render judgment one way or the other, depending on the choice you make.

    Will you despise correction, or embrace it? These intervening hours will reveal the truth. I pray that Truth will be your friend in the end of this matter, and not your judge.

    ~ Selah ~

    David Castelli

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s